Whitewell valley
Hawthornthwaite Fell
xxx
A free afternoon and a reported Woodchat Shrike in Bowland - no brainer really! Mid afternoon found me fighting the traffic heading north into the lakes - fortunately not too many delays. My destination was a small plantation near Tower Lodge - approx half way between Abbeystead and Dunsop Bridge. On arrival I found a birder who glumly pronounced that the bird had not been reported for three hours - however having seen it himself he could confirm it was a cracker!
xxx
I headed up the path behind the lodge and immediately a Redstart flashed across in front of me and off into the trees to the left. Tracking it, and losing it, I then located a Spotted Flycatcher and subsequently had stonking views of two of these birds in the tree. Great start! I then wandered along the track before emerging from the wood to immediately see, way in the distance, the Woodchat Shrike. A group of birders were already present and I eventually got some dodgy digiscope shots.
xxx
At this point things began to go pear shaped. One of the photographers (big lens) asked permission from the rest of us to enter the mossy field to get closer. We all agreed this was OK - bird was still a long way off and we all moved a bit closer. The photographer (and another one) however showed no field craft - instead of approaching slowly a bit at a time and giving the bird the opportunity to get used to people they simply marched straight over and flushed the bird. It flew into the trees west of the stream and stayed there for around 20 minutes. It then reappeared on a post further up the field nr the path.
xxx
At this point most of the birders wandered back to the path (the two photographers stayed put), kept their distance and enjoyed good views for approx 10 minutes. The bird then flew off (no flushing) into trees to the east. It stayed here for over 45 minutes and then suddenly reappeared back on the fence right in front of the photographers. It immediately disappeared and was not seen again - at this point I had wandered off down the path in search of Tree Pipits and saw all this from a distance.
xxx
I notice from the Lancaster website that a young, inexperienced birder in a white t-shirt is being blamed for this and not the "two experienced photographers who had quietly set themselves up in position". First one of the so-called experienced photographers was wearing a very pale shirt. Second the guy in the white t-shirt was neither young (est in 40's), inexperienced (he was picking up bird calls as they flew over that no one else was - I spent time talking to him) or near the photographers (approx 100 yds away). Well, there has to be a scapegoat.
xxx
The other annoying thing was that, when the Shrike was not on view, most of the birders simply stood and chatted. I was constantly scanning the nearby trees and hills - 3 Buzzards, a pair of Red Grouse, 4 Curlews plus singing Redstart and Tree Pipit were the rewards. I estimate between 30 and 40 Painted Ladies also flew through! I then left the site and headed off towards Whitewell, collecting another Buzzard, Raven, Stonechat, Common Sandpiper and 5 Oystercatchers as I went. Aside from the Buzzards the no-show from other raptors was slightly disappointing.
xxx
On the way home this evening I popped into Moor Piece - a male Pied Flycatcher was feeding a juvenile with a third bird seen briefly going into the nest box - nothing else of note. It was a glorious afternoon and evening though, good birds and stunning views of the hills - good to be back on home territory again!